2002 Senate Bill 1436 ↩

Senate Roll Call 1059: Failed

To adopt a House-Senate compromise version. See below.

19 Yeas / 12 Nays

Democrat (3 Yeas / 8 Nays)

Miller, Jr. (D-10) Peters (D-14) Young, Jr. (D-1)	Byrum (D-25) Cherry (D-28) DeBeaussaert (D-11) Dingell (D-7) Emerson (D-29) Leland (D-5) Scott (D-2) Smith (D-18)

Republican (16 Yeas / 4 Nays)

Bennett (R-8) Bullard (R-15) DeGrow (R-27) Dunaskiss (R-16) Emmons (R-23) Goschka (R-33) Hammerstrom (R-17) McManus, Jr. (R-36) North (R-37) Schuette (R-35) Schwarz (R-24) Shugars (R-21) Sikkema (R-31) Steil (R-30) Stille (R-32) Van Regenmorter (R-22)	Garcia (R-26) Hoffman (R-19) Johnson (R-13) Sanborn (R-12)

Excused or Not Voting (7)

Gougeon (R-34) Hart (D-6) Koivisto (D-38) Murphy (D-3) Vaughn (D-4) Gast (R-20) McCotter (R-9)