House Roll Call 5 - Michigan Votes

MichiganVotes.org: Michigan Laws, Bills and Votes
using concise, plain and objective descriptions

Legislation watch

House Roll Call 5 on
2011 House Bill 4135: Revise Detroit police and fire pension board selection

Passed 84 to 24 in the House on February 10, 2011.
See Who Voted "Yes" and Who Voted "No".

To prohibit Detroit police and fire unions from bargaining in contract negotiations over whether a retiree is selected to represent retired employees on the pension board. The unions have sued to stop the appointment of a retire on the board; there have extensive allegations of corruption related to this board. More details on this issue can be found in the House Fiscal Agency analysis.

View the rest of House Bill 4135: History, Amendments & Comments

Vote

In Favor

Against

Not Voting

Undecided

Republican

	100%
	0%
	0%

63 total votes

Democrat

	44%
	51%
	4%

47 total votes

Voters

	100%
	0%
	0%

1 total vote

Add to your scorecard as In Favor or Against (select a scorecard)

IN FAVOR

HOUSE DEMOCRATS

Schmidt, R. (D)

HOUSE REPUBLICANS

Knollenberg (R)

Schmidt, W. (R)

Shaughnessy (R)

AGAINST

HOUSE DEMOCRATS

Hovey-Wright (D)

HOUSE REPUBLICANS
none

HOUSE LEGISLATORS WHO DID NOT VOTE

HOUSE LEGISLATORS ORDERED BY NAME

Y Ananich (D-49)

n Barnett (D-37)

Y Bledsoe (D-1)

Y Bolger (R-63)

n Brunner (D-96)

Y Bumstead (R-100)

Y Callton (R-87)

Y Cavanagh (D-17)

Y Clemente (D-14)

Y Constan (D-16)

Y Cotter (R-99)

Y Crawford (R-38)

Y Damrow (R-84)

n Darany (D-15)

n Dillon (D-75)

Y Farrington (R-30)

Y Forlini (R-24)

Y Foster (R-107)

Y Franz (R-101)

Y Genetski (R-88)

Y Gilbert (R-81)

Y Glardon (R-85)

Y Haines (R-43)

n Hammel (D-48)

Y Haveman (R-90)

Y Hooker (R-77)

n Hovey-Wright (D-92)

Y Hughes (R-91)

Y Huuki (R-110)

n Jackson (D-9)

Y Jacobsen (R-46)

Y Jenkins (R-57)

Y Johnson (R-97)

n Kandrevas (D-13)

Y Knollenberg (R-41)

Y Kowall (R-44)

Y LaFontaine (R-32)

Y LeBlanc (D-18)

- Lindberg (D-109)

n Lipton (D-27)

Y MacGregor (R-73)

Y MacMaster (R-105)

Y McBroom (R-108)

n McCann (D-60)

Y McMillin (R-45)

Y Meadows (D-69)

Y Melton (D-29)

Y Muxlow (R-83)

n Nathan (D-11)

Y Nesbitt (R-80)

Y O'Brien (R-61)

Y Opsommer (R-93)

Y Ouimet (R-52)

Y Outman (R-70)

Y Pettalia (R-106)

Y Poleski (R-64)

Y Potvin (R-102)

Y Pscholka (R-79)

Y Rendon (R-103)

Y Rogers (R-66)

Y Rutledge (D-54)

n Santana (D-10)

Y Schmidt, R. (D-76)

Y Schmidt, W. (R-104)

Y Shaughnessy (R-71)

Y Shirkey (R-65)

n Slavens (D-21)

n Smiley (D-50)

Y Somerville (R-23)

- Stallworth (D-8)

Y Stamas (R-98)

Y Stanley (D-34)

Y Stapleton (D-4)

Y Switalski (D-25)

n Townsend (D-26)

Y Yonker (R-72)

House Roll Call 5 on 2011 House Bill 4135

Comments