2012 House Bill 5699 ↩

Senate Roll Call 562: The amendment was not adopted

To cut the income tax rate to zero.

16 Yeas / 21 Nays

Republican (8 Yeas / 18 Nays)

Caswell (R-16) Green (R-31) Hildenbrand (R-29) Hune (R-22) Jones (R-24) Nofs (R-19) Robertson (R-26) Rocca (R-10)	Booher (R-35) Brandenburg (R-11) Casperson (R-38) Colbeck (R-7) Emmons (R-33) Hansen (R-34) Jansen (R-28) Kahn (R-32) Kowall (R-15) Marleau (R-12) Meekhof (R-30) Moolenaar (R-36) Pappageorge (R-13) Pavlov (R-25) Proos (R-21) Richardville (R-17) Schuitmaker (R-20) Walker (R-37)

Democrat (8 Yeas / 3 Nays)

Bieda (D-9) Gleason (D-27) Gregory (D-14) Hood (D-3) Hunter (D-5) Johnson (D-2) Smith (D-4) Young (D-1)	Hopgood (D-8) Warren (D-18) Whitmer (D-23)

Excused or Not Voting (1)

Anderson (D-6)